He makes it plain that these examples forced his own feelings to an intolerable
tension. His intellectual perplexities had become resolved; the virtue of
continence had been consciously preferred; there was a strong desire for the
storms of his breast to be calmed; he longed to imitate these men who had done
what he could not and who were enjoying the peace he longed for.
But the old habits were still strong and he could not muster a full act of the
whole will to strike them down. Then comes the scene in the Milanese garden
which is an interesting parallel to Ponticianus' story about the garden at
Treves. The long struggle is recapitulated in a brief moment; his will
struggles against and within itself. The trivial distraction of a child's
voice, chanting, "Tolle, lege," precipitates the resolution of the
conflict. There is a radical shift in mood and will, he turns eagerly to the
chance text in Rom. 13:13--and a new spirit rises in his heart.
After this radical change, there was only one more past event that had to be
relived before his personal history could be seen in its right perspective.
This was the death of his mother and the severance of his strongest earthly
tie. Book IX tells us this story. The climactic moment in it is, of course, the
vision at Ostia where mother and son are uplifted in an ecstasy that
parallels--but also differs significantly from--the Plotinian vision of Book
VII. After this, the mother dies and the son who had loved her almost too much
goes on alone, now upheld and led by a greater and a wiser love.
We can observe two separate stages in Augustine's "conversion." The first was
the dramatic striking off of the slavery of incontinence and pride which had so
long held him from decisive commitment to the Christian faith. The second was
the development of an adequate understanding of the Christian faith itself and
his baptismal confession of Jesus Christ as Lord and Saviour. The former was
achieved in the Milanese garden. The latter came more slowly and had no
"dramatic moment." The dialogues that Augustine wrote at Cassiciacum the year
following his conversion show few substantial signs of a theological
understanding, decisively or distinctively Christian. But by the time of his
ordination to the presbyterate we can see the basic lines of a comprehensive
and orthodox theology firmly laid out. Augustine neglects to tell us (in 398)
what had happened in his thought between 385 and 391. He had other questions,
more interesting to him, with which to wrestle.
One does not read far in the Confessions before he recognizes that the
term "confess" has a double range of meaning. On the one hand, it obviously
refers to the free acknowledgment, before God, of the truth one knows about
oneself--and this obviously meant, for Augustine, the "confession of sins."
But, at the same time, and more importantly, confiteri means to
acknowledge, to God, the truth one knows about God. To confess, then, is to
praise and glorify God; it is an exercise in self-knowledge and true humility
in the atmosphere of grace and reconciliation.
Thus the Confessions are by no means complete when the personal history
is concluded at the end of Book IX. There are two more closely related problems
to be explored: First, how does the finite self find the infinite God (or, how
is it found of him?)? And, secondly, how may we interpret God's action in
producing this created world in which such personal histories and revelations
do occur? Book X, therefore, is an exploration of man's way to God, a
way which begins in sense experience but swiftly passes beyond it, through and
beyond the awesome mystery of memory, to the ineffable encounter between God
and the soul in man's inmost subject-self. But such a journey is not complete
until the process is reversed and man has looked as deeply as may be into the
mystery of creation, on which all our history and experience depend. In Book
XI, therefore, we discover why time is such a problem and how "In the
beginning God created the heavens and the earth" is the basic formula of a
massive Christian metaphysical world view. In Books XII and XIII, Augustine
elaborates, in loving patience and with considerable allegorical license, the
mysteries of creation--exegeting the first chapter of Genesis, verse by verse,
until he is able to relate the whole round of creation to the point where we
can view the drama of God's enterprise in human history on the vast stage of
the cosmos itself. The Creator is the Redeemer! Man's end and the beginning
meet at a single point!
The Enchiridion is a briefer treatise on the grace of God and represents
Augustine's fully matured theological perspective--after the magnificent
achievements of the De Trinitate and the greater part of the De
civitate Dei, and after the tremendous turmoil of the Pelagian controversy
in which the doctrine of grace was the exact epicenter. Sometime in 421,
Augustine received a request from one Laurentius, a Christian layman who was
the brother of the tribune Dulcitius (for whom Augustine wrote the De octo
dulcitii quaestionibus in 423-425). This Laurentius wanted a handbook
(enchiridion) that would sum up the essential Christian teaching in the
briefest possible form. Augustine dryly comments that the shortest complete
summary of the Christian faith is that God is to be served by man in faith,
hope, and love. Then, acknowledging that this answer might indeed be too
brief, he proceeds to expand it in an essay in which he tries
unsuccessfully to subdue his natural digressive manner by imposing on it a
patently artificial schematism. Despite its awkward form, however, the
Enchiridion is one of the most important of all of Augustine's writings,
for it is a conscious effort of the theological magistrate of the Western
Church to stand on final ground of testimony to the Christian truth.
For his framework, Augustine chooses the Apostles' Creed and the Lord's Prayer.
The treatise begins, naturally enough, with a discussion of God's work in
creation. Augustine makes a firm distinction between the comparatively
unimportant knowledge of nature and the supremely important acknowledgment of
the Creator of nature. But creation lies under the shadow of sin and evil and
Augustine reviews his famous (and borrowed!) doctrine of the privative
character of evil. From this he digresses into an extended comment on error and
lying as special instances of evil. He then returns to the hopeless case of
fallen man, to which God's wholly unmerited grace has responded in the
incarnation of the Mediator and Redeemer, Jesus Christ. The questions about the
appropriation of God's grace lead naturally to a discussion of baptism and
justification, and beyond these, to the Holy Spirit and the Church. Augustine
then sets forth the benefits of redeeming grace and weighs the balance between
faith and good works in the forgiven sinner. But redemption looks forward
toward resurrection, and Augustine feels he must devote a good deal of energy
and subtle speculation to the questions about the manner and mode of the life
everlasting. From this he moves on to the problem of the destiny of the wicked
and the mystery of predestination. Nor does he shrink from these grim topics;
indeed, he actually expands some of his most rigid ideas of God's
ruthless justice toward the damned. Having thus treated the Christian faith and
Christian hope, he turns in a too-brief concluding section to the virtue of
Christian love as the heart of the Christian life. This, then, is the
"handbook" on faith, hope, and love which he hopes Laurence will put to use and
not leave as "baggage on his bookshelf."